Where’s the evidence for assessment?

Posted by John Kleeman

I’m always on the lookout for hard evidence that assessment improves learning outcomes, and I’m indebted to Denise Whitelock, Lester Gilbert and Veronica Gale for alerting me to some powerful evidence in their research report at the 2011 CAA Conference. This Australian study looked at more than 1500 students taking part in an applied maths course and showed that taking formative quizzes during a course improved learning outcomes.

The study was conducted by two economics lecturers, Dr Simon Angus and Judith Watson, and is titled Does regular online testing enhance student learning in the numerical sciences? Robust evidence from a large data set. It was published in the peer-reviewed British Journal of Educational Technology Vol 40 No 2, 255-272 in 2009.

Angus and Watson introduced a series of 4 online, formative quizzes into the course, and wanted to determine whether students who took the quizzes learned more and did better on the final exam than those who didn’t. The interesting thing about the study is that they used a statistical technique (ordinary least squares regression). This allowed them to estimate the effect of several different factors, and isolate the effects of taking the quizzes from the previous mathematical experience of the students, their gender and their general level of effort to determine which impacted the final exam score most.

You can see a summary of their findings in the graph below, which shows the estimated coefficients for four of the main factors, all of which had a statistical significance of p < 0.01.

Factors associated with final exam score graph

You can see from this graph that the biggest factor associated with final exam success was how well students had done in the midterm exam, i.e. how well they were doing in the course generally. But students who took the 4 online quizzes learned from them and did significantly better. The impact of taking or not taking the quizzes was broadly the same as the impact of their prior maths education: quite reasonable and significant.

We know intuitively that formative quizzes help learning, but it’s nice to see a statistical proof that – to quote the authors – “exposure to a regular (low mark) online quiz instrument has a significant and positive effect on student learning as measured by an end of semester examination”.

Comments

  1. October 11th, 2011 | 11:32 am

    I recommend you read Andrew C. Butler’s article, “Repeated Testing Produces Superior Transfer of Learning Relative to Repeated Studying,” in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition (2010, Vol. 36, No. 5, 1118–1133). He found that repeated testing (with feedback – that is important!) had a positive effect on final test performance.

Leave a reply

SAP Microsoft Oracle HR-XML AAIC